We were in Wal-Mart earlier, and on the Valentine's Day crap aisle, they had some great tickling-oriented toys for the upcoming holiday.
One item was a set of plastic handcuffs with a feather attached! They were even called "Fuzzy Cuffs with Tickler".
Another item was a Valentine's Day Voodoo Doll, in red, with various playful phrases on it, like "Kiss me like you mean it", "Sweep me off my feet", "Slow dance with me to our song", "Love me", and right there in the middle of the torso? "Tickle me"!
So, yeah. Maybe it is more "mainstream" or whatever. Great! :super_hap