Hmm I'm possibly a tough one to please when it comes to comedy - especially stand-up/live comedy and especially when I'm watching stand-up/live comedy on television
I always get this sense that the comedian is not as funny as everyone watching seems to think - I sit and cringe as the camera cuts to people in the audience slapping their legs in raucous hysterics and throwing themselves around in the chair red-faced and clapping - I sometimes think the audience is slightly duped into finding something funnier than it actually is, either by way of their participation in the excitement and atmosphere of actually being there live, or by the actual delivery of the jokes (the delivery can often be funnier than the joke itself and can carry the joke way beyond the punchline, but can equally become quite predictable and exhausting if not varied).
I also find that the base of the jokes and the dialogue style of delivery to the audience often replicates the sort of conversations you might have with a group of friends when sat around telling funny stories about past experiences, day to day troubles and the characters you encounter along the way - with friends the joke can be funnier because there's a personal element involved, personal memories etc and everyone bounces off each other with funny comments.....but it can also be less funny, because that comic delivery is not necessarily there.
From what I've seen, I like Katherine Ryan, Rich Hall, Frank Skinner and Dara O Briain. I don't like Frankie Boyle, Harry Hill or Russell Howard
I have not idea what a roast is, but it seems to be a series of comedy specials with different comedians? Probably rather like the Saturday Night at the Apollo that's popular in the UK
Anyway, don't call me grumpy just yet...I do love some comedy 🙂 I'll to try lump some examples into genres, I'm not sure how many of these shows will be know outside of UK, but here are some:
I like real life candid/hidden camera comedy - like the Impractical Jokers others have mentioned..
I like un-scripted, quick-witted, creative and often topical comedy - for example comedy quiz shows like 'Have I Got News For You'
I like sketch shows (which can be very hit and miss, but when they are good they are very good) eg some of the Harry Enfield stuff.
I like farcical situation/character comedy - eg Dad's Army, Vicar of Dibley, InBetweeners
I like situation comedy where there's also a story, so sad and thought provoking things actually happen as well - eg One Foot in the Grave, Gavin & Stacey
And I don't mind going to see a comedy play or musical at the theatre, although productions can often be very unforgiving if the performers/script are not top notch.
Cheers
TTG