I'm one of those Metallica snobs who happens to believe that Metallica ten minutes ago was better than Metallica presently...so I'm not really a person to gauge anything by, but the short answer would be "no." After Black Album, Metallica sort of lost their magic. Their greatest attempts to recover what they had lost, IMO, was S&M and Garage, Inc., but even those were a bit too new-Metallica for me.