You all may remember that the Pam Anderson episode happened because they were deluged with emails. A week later he did the same thing to Carmen Electra. Then a week later he did it again to Brande Roderick and also brought it up to Julianna Marguilles and Kyra Sedgewick (and possibly others). I know that there have been other guests in the past few months that he's been emailed heavily about and nothing happened. He can't tickle EVERY guest! It's worth a try, and out of unity I'll even send an email (even though I personally don't care much for either Jenna nor Tori Spelling....I'd rather wait until he gets Josie Moran or Kylie Bax or Cindy Margolis or lots of other celeb-babes come in again!), but if he gets pestered every time a new female guest comes on, it could backfire. In fact, that could be why he hasn't continued all along.
But let me not be so negative. I hope it happens (of course, I'd be happy if he got either of them as well) and especially for Brooklyn!
Better yet Brooklyn, you should contact the show about coming on yourself and doing the honors!!! THAT'S the kind of thing he might do....call up, beg him to come on (he'll probably dare you to do something crazy, like dress up in bikini and take a bath with Benji, but you just might be rewarded with the holy grail of opportunities!). Hell, you could even be a regular, like the foot fetish guy that judged the Playmates toes!
I'm just rambling, hope this contributed something.