I tend to be like the guys above, in that the now-accepted ideal of a pron-star, with the gravity-defying, ridiculous fake breasts, big-hair, botox lips, tramp-stamp, and so on, does surprisingly little for me, too.
There was, however, a gal back in the late 80's/early 90's era who went by the name simply "Flame", who was such a hot little thing. She didn't have the typical look, but had stunning red hair, freckles, gorgeous pale skin, and was alittle on the "plump" side(for pron gals). She would be "It" for me. Sadly, I have no pix of her. She did do some shots for various Lyndon and HOM mags back in the day, which is how I originally came to know of her. I was doubly surprised later to see her in standard pron vids, too. beautiful woman, anyway.