Super Bowl Question V

[Dave2112]

Ok, on to the Philly question...

Let's say you're Andy Reid. After a hearty breakfast of Moon Pies and Cheesesteaks, you sit down to decide who starts at quarterback, with the red-hot Falcons coming to town. McNabb is better, but your back-ups have been playing tremendously. You have no idea how rusty Donovan might be, and the Divisional round might not be the time to find out. What do you do?

Start McNabb? Stick with what's worked? Start McNabb on a short leash? Alternate QB's in different situations?

Your call, coach!

 

[amk714]

Start McNabb, but have Feely ready at a moment's notice. (Glad I'm not in Andy Reid's shoes.) Go Philly! (Now that Green Bay's out.) 🙂

 

[primetime]

you have to start with your "franchise" player. if he messes up, then you put in the backups. AJ Feeley isnt like a Marc Bulger of the St. Louis Rams. Feeley is just doing enough not to screw it all up. McNabb is the lifeblood of that team. you have to start him.

 

[Prime]

i say they have to go with mcnabb if he is even close to ready. what i saw of feeley in phily's last game he it did'nt looked like reid trusted him to throw alot. I hav'nt followed the eagles this season but that doesnt bode well for his confidence in the guy. Like someone else said, it looks like he is just doing enuf not to lose. So they have to go with mcnabb unless he gets hurt or cant go. I will be rooting for the falcons though. Vick against Mcnabb with be an awesome display.