Baseball's Greatest Alltime Players

[GEORGIATKLER]

Since Spring Training ( And Hopefully Springtime Weather) Is Just Around The Corner, Who Would You Select As The Three (or More If You Wish) Greatest Baseball Players Ever? I'll Go With Ty Cobb ( We Georgia Boys Must Stick Together!) Willie Mays (the Greatest Ever Imho) And Ted Williams ( Frozen Or Thawed)! "we Don't Need No Stinkin' Yankees"!

 

[naveltkltr1350]

top three..id take Nolan Ryan, Hank Aaron , and Johnny Bench

 

[HOLLYWOOD]

tough call. i think i have to say hall of fame pitcher steve carlton for winning over half of the phillies game himself one season, joe dimaggio for his brillant fielding, and mike schmidt for his hitting. keep in mind mike hit all those home runs without the fancy weight trainign and steriods and supplements that athletes use today

 

[tummynavelboy]

Come on You forgot to mention Ken Griffey Jr.

even though he's been hurt like every year which is a shame seattle should have never let me go. He was a major key player for the marniers.

 

[tosman82]

MO VAUGHN lol

 

[tummynavelboy]

MO VAUGHN lol

Mo Vaughn lol

um NO

 

[MayDay1]

I'll take Ricky "Wild Thing" Vaughn over Mo Vaughn.

 

[escargot0071]

Ken Griffey?? Are you kidding? biggest dissapointment ever! Alright ive thought about this question a lot since i do nothing but eat sleep and drink baseball. My dream team consists of:

Nolan Ryan, Walter Johnson, Cy Young, Christy Mathewson, and Roger Clemens.
My closer would be Mariano Rivera.

As for the line up, Id have Johnny Bench at catcher, Eddie Murray at First, Second Base give me Pete Rose and put him in the hall for crying out loud, Shortstop Cal Ripken Jr. (BALTIMORE ORIOLES BABY!!!) 3rd Base...Mike Schmidt, as for my 3 outfielders id take Ted Williams, Babe Ruth, and Hank Arron and ill take Ty Cobb as my DH.

 

[Tkpro]

Barry Bonds, Babe Ruth, Ted Williams

 

[HOLLYWOOD]

it is very tough. if i was adding to my list i would go with a first baseman for the rochester redwings called calvin pickering. this guy is hilarious to watch and i have enver seen a player get the crowd into such a frenzy so quickly every time he comes to bat. he may not be in the same league as a pete rose but he gets a bigger crowd reaction which baseball loves. i would also add kofax, ryan, sanberg, joe morgan, john kruk, vin scully, harry kallas, ripkin, boggs, he yankees owner nad the babe himself

 

[naveltkltr1350]

it is very tough. if i was adding to my list i would go with a first baseman for the rochester redwings called calvin pickering. this guy is hilarious to watch and i have enver seen a player get the crowd into such a frenzy so quickly every time he comes to bat. he may not be in the same league as a pete rose but he gets a bigger crowd reaction which baseball loves. i would also add kofax, ryan, sanberg, joe morgan, john kruk, vin scully, harry kallas, ripkin, boggs, he yankees owner nad the babe himself

the yankees owner as in steinbrenner?? i really dont like him..where im from this city had a ship building company that steinbrenner owned and my grandfather worked there..he closed the door on all the hard workers and took all their benifits away..he kinda screwed them all..ppl in this area HATE stienbrenner.I dislike him also. thats my 2cents. the rest of ur picks are good tho