I rarely watch that Buffy show but have recently found myself obsessed with Alyson Hannigan......damn she's cute......she plays "Willow", right? I hope so because I cast my vote accordingly.
My thoughts exactly! And she probably would have been the top pick, 'cuz she was by FAR the hottest chick on that show. Absent that, Sarah/Buffy has a great laugh so I could see why she won, though I personally would rather tickle Alyson/Willow (my pick).
Upon reflection, maybe Cordelia was left out because she also starred in the 'Buffy' spinoff, 'Angel'??? That show had enough hot women perhaps to merit its own poll.
But that doesn't explain why Dawn (Michelle Trachtenberg) was also omitted. Sure, she was just a kid when she came aboard, but by the end of the Buffy series she had grown enough to deserve a spot. I can certainly recall wanting to give her character a good tickling often enough.