Nice arches, nice toe shape, they look smooth, tiny bit dirty but not bad. To really give a full rating I'd have to see the tops as well. Also I'd need you to confirm their smoothness. And one last question. How ticklish are they?
I'm gonna go off on a limb here and assume that if you had a conversation with her about the TMF and she even allowed you to hold and photograph her feet up close, it's fair to assume that you either popped the question "are you ticklish?" Or just as likely took the initiative and tried tickling them yourself. So... are they ticklish and hoe bad?