TMF Classic Rock Vote-Off (Round 13)

[Dave2112]

Hey guys. Sorry for the delay. Things. Been to a weird place.

Anyhoo, quickly (sorry for the lack of preamble, just wanted to get this going),

Foreigner over Boston 16-9

Jethro Tull over Styx 15-11

So, Round 13....

This one pits to true classics and groundbreakers against one another.

The Who vs. Cream

Entwistle/Bruce.....Clapton/Townsend....Moon/Baker

You decide!

 

[RobAce]

If this was about soloists, or which members did the best I would vote Cream.

But looking at the works of both bands I went with The Who.

Behind Blue Eyes and Pinball Wizard alone put The Who over the top.

Hell I even liked You Better You Bet more than most of Cream's music.

Rob

 

[Tick L]

This is a hard one... two great bands, but I gotta go with The Who, based on the same reasoning as Rob really. They're just an overall better band than Cream as a whole I believe.

 

[lk70]

Behind Blue Eyes...what a song. The Who.

 

[General Zod]

The Who rule

WOW WHO THE FU#K ARE YOU

 

[Saeria]

Hmm lets see... Seeing as how i always envisioned myself getting thrown in jail for climbing onto stage and begging Roger Daltrey to carry my love children, i'd have to go with The Who.

 

[aurora5150]

the who hands down.

 

[Soda Bobinski]

Who wins this ...? The Who wins this.

 

[TklDuo-Drew]

Cream!!!!!!!


The Who was great but Cream has so many better songs.....and NOT just the hits.


Drew

 

[dman68]

I love both bands, voted Cream just because I like their songs better than the who but that is a tough one.

 

[OmahaLerLee]

listen to quadrophenia and tell me who wins. seriously.

cream... meh.

 

[maniactickler]

Cream was great, but i went with the Who.

 

[milagros317]

For this one I have a clear preference: The Who.

 

[nostradamas]

Who Are You ??? Who's Next ???

Two of the great albums of all time.

Other songs not mentioned:

Boris the Spider
Pictures of Lilly
Squeeze Box
My Generation
Magic Bus
Baba O' Riley
I Can See For Miles
I'm a Boy
Kids are Alright
Substitute
The Seeker
Happy Jack
Won't Get Fooled Again
My Wife
The Relay
5:15
Love Reign O'er Me
I Can't Explain
Anyway, Anyhow, Anywhere

Then there's Tommy - The greatest Rock Opera of all time.

The Who
Not even close.

 

[ticklesaurus]

If I could go back in time,Cream is definately a group I would have loved to of seen live.I have seen The Who many times and have most of thier music.....must go with The Who.

 

[JPie1]

Madonna....ooops wrong thread

 

[lk70]

Madonna....ooops wrong thread

Hee hee. She funny girl.