Yes, it is quite silly. I agree with you and ness on that. However, I do have a couple things to say about your other thoughts on this...
First off, can you show me the exact thread in which you started and it was frowned upon? You could easily be right and maybe this whole thing isn't a good idea but I wish to see the thread that you made first, if I may. I'm thinking that your thread may have had a similar concept as this one but it may have been frowned upon for other reasons that this thread could avoid. Basically, i'm asking if you could give me a link to the thread you started that was frowned upon so I can see for myself whether or not this thread will most likely be frowned upon as well and if we should just close it now.
Secondly, I agree that there is the possibility of the whole excluding, competitive issue. But i'm pretty sure people here are mature enough to except the fact if someone is nominated, it doesn't necessarily have to be them. This is just a fun little thread for people's hardwork or good personality to be recognized. I mean c'mon. The members on TT are mature. If we see people who are funny, hardworking, or whatever category there is, then we nominate them. The chances of something like "Oh, you're my friend, I should nominate you because of this" or "I don't like this guy. I say he shouldn't be nominated at all" posts are slim to none. I'm sure Ex or Helen wouldn't create a category for something like "Biggest loser on TT" or something that may seem offensive as well so I really don't see how this can turn out to be something that big of a deal. In a worst case scenario, if a member thinks he/she can't handle who we nominate, thenI reccomend just not viewing the thread at all. Simple as that.
Now the whole "if I was denied creating such an award ceremony, then so should everyone else be, on fair principle." thing really sounds like a "if I have to suffer for something, so should everyone else" kinda thing. I really don't think it's necessary to deny this thread just because yours was frowned upon.
I say, let this thread go for a little bit. If members are offended for whatever reason or if your thread is indeed the same as ours and was frowned upon, then fine. I say close it. But let a mod be the judge of that. Let's just see how this thread does for a couple days, ok? If it doesn't go down with the members very well, then I will request that a mod close it, but only for something like that. I know our mods and admin are very responsible and do their job very well, so I have no doubt that they will choose the right decision for closing it or not. Leave it up to a mod. Report this thread if anything. A mod will check it and either give an approval or a thumbs down.
Edit: Holy shiat, I had no idea I was capable of typing so much.