Jerry,
Your response was indeed well-written, but respectfully, I do have some problems with it.
Seems to me your "people are just people; generalizations can't be made about personalities in a group" (my synopsis) is not only politically correct, it's wishful thinking. What if we were talking about sadomasochism fetishists -- would you make the same forceful argument against any generalizations about
their personalities? I don't think so. How about people who like to cut themselves? Would it be misguided to generalize about their poor socializations? Hardly.
Then the fair question becomes not whether generalizing ever makes sense, but whether ticking fetishists are the kind of group to which social dysfunction can be correlated (i.e. is tickling like a softball club, or is it like an S&M club, even a little bit?)
And at the risk of repeating myself, I don't feel
I'm socially dysfunctional. And Jerry, I suspect
you're not socially dysfunctional either. But
is there a correlation between this community in general and social dysfunction? At all?
I suspect there is, and at least some people have been agreeing with me.
There is one great rule for successful parties. People make a party. If you know the organizers and they seem like together people, take a chance and attend if you are lucky enough to be invited.
That's just it, we wouldn't know the organizers, nor most of the people going. We're talking about a meet-up posted online, through this website or another, where the precise problem, and the genesis of this discussion, is not only that you haven't met the other people going, but the party throwers haven't either. In fact, by you invoking the standard "if you know the organizers," I can almost infer that if you
don't know the organizers... you'd agree it may be problematic. In other words, it appears that by your own standard, I have a point. (And now that I clarified my scenario, maybe you'll agree.)
Once again folks, I'm not trying to start a flame war, or insult anyone personally. It is, however, something I've been thinking about and wanted to get a sense of the reaction.
Oh, and I wish I'd titled the original post, "Are Many of You Poorly Socialized" -- "Weird" was the wrong word as it triggers a kind of "Revenge of the Nerds" defense reaction which gets in the way, and just about everyone has at one time considered themselves weird (including me) -- while a tiny fraction consider themselves "poorly socialized." Poorly socialized is what I really meant anyway.