Celtic_Emperor
3rd Level White Feather
- Joined
- Nov 20, 2002
- Messages
- 9,620
- Points
- 0
nerrad said:Well there's a vote of confidence. Thanks!
Nope. I like the idea of seeing different approaches to the same scenario. I think the word "contest" got people bunched up from the beginning and now everyone is overthinking it. I only used anime as an example of where it'd be okay to judge. Knowing that it's style has large eyes, unique highlights in hair, etc... things you can always look for... it makes it okay to say [for example] "Vlad really nailed the anime style on this one. It looks pro. Line weight is good and the coloring is consistent." But you can't compare the art of Masters of the Universe to Beavis and Butthead or everyone will say B&B loses because it sucks by comparison. It looks scribbled. Southpark blows them away with ratings and merchandising and it looks like Helen Keller draws for them. So what's better?
If you want a level playing field, do something simple that won't exclude people not into anime, cat people, role playing, etc. And make them generic characters so you don't have to try to mimic the style of the Family Guy or some other recognizable cartoon. Otherwise people just be copying stuff. Throw out a scenario, number of characters, specify a gender, an area being worked over, etc and let them run.
I also think it'd be interesting for people to do a line drawing and let someone else color it. Someone can take the submissions and distribute them and see what comes back. At one of my past companies, we used to take 15 minutes and do a floor plan for a trade show. Then we'd take our floor plan and pass it to the person two chairs down to the left and they would draw a perspective drawing based on what they thought our floor plan was showing. We got some nice stuff out of it. Again, just a thought, but it opens your mind to a new look at your stuff. If you put 100 drawings from the forum down in front of me, I could tell you who did them. People draw inside boxes for the most part and experiment very little. There are a few exceptions here and you know who you are. But I'd like to see Vlad color an Umojar and Ness color a Snail Shell or Kalamos color a Cheshire, etc. It's all in fun, so don't reply about artistic integrity.
I want to again say that we haven't even agreed upon a theme to draw from. Once we do the artists will agree to draw something that has to do with it. For it to be fair it should be something not associated with what they're best at, otherwise its not a personal challenge and its a give-away with the other artists. Anime is the common theme on this site, so it should be removed. If the artists had to draw an animal, like a bird or a fruit like an apple, that would be more challenging than it appears, since no one here has displayed a previous aptitude in those types of things.
It will put the artists in uncharted territory, and THATS what makes this fair as they're all in the same situation. What will help an artist out however is their ability to transition and adapt. Some will naturally be able to do this better than others. How do we deal with them and what do we say about it?
I am very glad that you are seeing what I am meaning.
Last edited: