I'm not saying it is either. What I said is when the help they need fails, or they just become more agressive because they've finally wised up to the fact they're being treated differently, that perhaps inevitably, the only way they're learn a lesson is through the means which they dish out their feelings. Speak to them in their language if all else fails. Not as something premediated, God no, but if it happens it happens. And it may be for the better. You never know how a mind works.
If its home abuse, or whatever, then of course its not something that would help. But then again you can't really tell now can you. They're too proud to admit they're scared and weak.
As for the failing school system, I don't think its right to attribute what I said about athletes to that as well. Even when the public school system was good and no child was being "left behind" by being allowing to move forward, jocks have always recieved special treatment, merely because they are a face for the school. Its greed like that thats dangerous.
You're not helping the kid, you're hurting him. He needs to learn like everyone else, not play patsy to some tri-county school board face-off. This is like a lesser extent of those "little league dads/moms" who push their kids into baseball (or any other sport they failed at in their time) and live through their kid and pressure him/her.