Oh, I see whatcha did there, Rick. 😉
OK, let me address this to the various members and the staff here. It's rather general, and I just woke up. :blink
First off, it's funny that it's been mentioned, because I was just thinking on this last night and there IS a new and growing sociology of the internet. Facebook, Twitter and all of that stuff are taking the internet in a new direction. Now, if you're an attention *****...you can get your attention faster and customize it to your specifications. Even group-based sites like FetLife are eating into the message board market. And speaking of markets...once message boards and forums go the way of the old stuff like AMT (probably by the end of this decade if not WAY sooner given the speed at which we as a species follow shiny objects), advertisers will be more picky. Hell, even the TMF may eventually wind up with a front page not plastered with ads. (I mean, come on...a poker site ad on a fetish forum? That just screams "I'm doing this for the money.")
Ok, so what do we do here, and now?
Although I know many of the staff and admins (who's left anyway?) don't like to wade into or even host discussions of a political nature...open topics like that DO keep people talking and that engagement spills out into the rest of the board. Let's look at what TT HAS going for it. It's a far more friendly spot for the creative element. People should probably be commenting more on new material or putting up new material of their own. (And yeah, I'm to blame for some of that, too. I really need to get on another creative streak.)
As much as we don't want to become another forum where the shit flings back and forth...we do need more avenues of expression. But here's where I think it could work here. On TT, it can be moderated evenly. With the social make-up of this site, there's no danger of the biggest creator of personal tension with free expression...
...favoritism. The staff here don't have a special clique of their own friends/partners/young girls they wanna fuck/said girls' whiteknights and all that crap. That is the one solitary thing that makes people hesitate to take part if they're not on that list. Here, we don't have it.
I think we could do well with a subforum for serious discussions of a political/religious/news-based nature. It just needs to be moderated with more attention. Hell, I'd even volunteer to keep an eye on it. I think the folks here could have serious discussions, get involved with each other's ideas and even disagree with civility. And yes, we're GOING to disagree. We're humans, we're always going to disagree on things like God vs. Science, Left vs. Right...but that's what we do. That's what makes us interesting. And so what if some topics get heated? As long as it's properly moderated, it can work.
And, that doesn't mean we have to have a subforum for every possible topic. We don't need a subforum for gamers, one for sports, one for silly shit. So much of that falls under GD and if people are comfortable having open or even sometimes heated discussions, I guarantee you'll see more activity in GD.
In closing, I think a lot of it is simply a matter of having a staff of moderators willing to be actively involved and willing to take the chance on opening some new avenues. Plus, the members need to speak out more...and those two go hand in hand.