So you're saying that just cause a guy does something OUTSIDE the actual olympic competition, and you say that taints him? This isn't Manny Ramirez or Rafael Palmeiro, two guys who were caught doing PEDs in season by the drug screening process. Yes Phelps should be held accountable for what he did, but for god sakes people, is ONE photo enough to change an entire opinion of a person when he's done everything by the book basically for his entire life? I honestly think the reaction to the picture was very overblown, mainly again by the Morality Police the same people that brought us Nipplegate, that can't just let a person do as he pleases. They have to do what they want or else basically. I guarantee once things start to heat up for London coming up for 2012, this will be a distant memory.
And to the point of him being a role model....I think Charles Barkley said it best when he said that he wasn't one himself, or that he shouldn't be one.
When you become a celebrity or famous athlete, people are going emulate you and make you their role models. It comes with the deal, no matter what Mr. Barkley says. It doesn't matter whether you want to or not. Kids will use successful athletes as models of what they became. I remember an interview of Greg Louganis (sp?) during one of the Olympics when he told of a meet he was competing in early in his career. He was a smoker then and had snuck out for a quick puff. Some young kids (12-ish I think he said) saw him smoking and walked up to him asking for some cigarettes from him as well. When he told them it was bad for them and they shouldn't, one of them quickly replied that Greg smoked and he was a champion diver, so if he wanted to be as good as Greg, he needed to start smoking. Greg put his cigarette out and stopping smoking from then on. And yes, I agree with Mr. Barkley that parents should be role models, but kids will pick out others as well.
At every meet Michael Phelps goes to from now on, there will always be whispers about the pic. Don't surprised if rumors start that he is doping with EPO or other drugs. After all, they'll say if he does pot, maybe he uses other drugs. An easy logical conclusion that human nature will create. Personally, I don't think he's that dumb and stupid, but you can't un-pop a balloon.
And, as for Manny, Rafael, A-Rod, Sammy, Barry and the rest, I agree with Bob Costas' take. If they get in the Hall of Fame, there should be a separate section for them and anyone who tests positive says what their records were, but they were on PED's. Personally, I think none should be allowed in.
And in final regards to Michael Phelps, I know what it is like to have your career ruined by a single mistake. It does happen. I resurrected mine. He can with his. My son said he read a report saying the bong pic was PhotoShopped and was originally a pic of him using an oxygen mask, with the bog 'shopped in. I've never seen the alleged photo, so I don't know if his report is accurate or not. I hope Mr. Phelps can overcome this mistake. But, he knows it will always be a part of his legacy. The piranha-like mentality of paparazzi and yellow journalism will make sure of that.