Ignatz, Licensed Theological Mahout
There is an old fable about six blind men who went to see an elephant. The first man went up to the creature and felt of its trunk. He exclaimed, "Ah ha! The elephant is very like a serpent!" One of his companions, however, fetched up against the side of the beast and cried, "No, no, it is like a wall!" The blind man who chanced to catch hold of an ear announced that an elephant is like a fan, and the one who found a tusk compared it to a spear. The blind man who grabbed the tail thought the elephant was rope-like and the one with his arms wrapped around a leg insisted that elephants are like trees.
This has been used as a metaphor for many things, but mostly as a parable of Man's search for God. Jews, Christians, Muslims, Hindus, Buddhists...each has a death grip on a different part of the Elephant. None is wrong about what he grasps, but neither does any of them see the whole creature. As a Christian, though, I necessarily believe that we understand more of the whole picture than the others do. (I like to think of an atheist as being the guy who got hold of the tail just as the elephant took a dump. He quits the scene in disgust, not realizing that he just had his nose rubbed in something strong, fertile and vital to the continuance of Life. But maybe I'm pushing the analogy too far.)
I was brought up as a Christian, fell away and was a practicing heathen for the better part of two decades, and then returned to the fold. I had no blinding Damascus-road experience; I simply wore out much of my youthful arrogance (and ignorance) and, largely through the reading of certain authors, became convinced of the truth of Christianity.
My reasons are many and varied, ranging from the metaphysical to the practical to the purely emotional.
I believe in God because...
*Big Bang and Steady State theories of the universe demand it.
*Human civilization's explosion on the timeline of Earth's history has "miracle" written all over it.
*Our conscience cannot be explained by any other means. As Dostoevsky put it, "If there is no God, then everything is permissible."
*Babies have a sense of humor.
*Nothing else can account for the music of Johann Sebastian Bach.
I believe in Christ because the Gospels have the ring of truth about them. This Jesus was either a madman or a liar (neither of which is tenable when you consider what he said and did)...or he was exactly what he said he was.
There are inconsistencies and contradictions in the Scriptures, but they are about relatively insignificant things...and they are the sort of mistakes you would expect to find in any accounts of something that actually happened. If it all fit and dovetailed perfectly, then I would suspect that it was something somebody made up.
The Old Testament is a collection of religious literature handed down by our spiritual fathers, the Jews. It is myth, parable, history, geneology, prophecy, poetry and proverb. Some of it is arguably satirical, like the Book of Jonah. This idea will outrage many of my fellow Christians, who do not understand that myth and satire are used to convey profound truths. Whatever is not literally true is still there to teach us a lesson about life and God.
To anyone who wishes to investigate the claims of Christianity, I would recommend one book, "Mere Christianity," by C. S. Lewis. Lewis builds up the case for, first, the existence of God, and then the divinity of Christ. He explains the doctrines that are common to all sects and denominations (hence, the title..."mere" as in "pure," not as in "paltry.") He does not gush or rhapsodize or holler "Hosanna." He writes a crystal clear prose that is a pleasure to read.
Anyone who would rather investigate the metaphysical reasons for believing in God, without involving Christianity or any other specific creed, should read "How To Think About God," by the late Mortimer J. Adler.