I am a woman. I am attractive, fit and fun. Men have been telling me I'm beautiful and sexy my whole life. Yet, I've always struggled getting them to tickle me.
My experience with my first boyfriend messed me up pretty bad. I was insecure about my fetish so I wrote him a letter explaining it. I was too shy to explain out loud. We talked about the letter and he said something like "I hate being tickled, but I will tickle you for sure!" And then....nothing. I literally got tickled maybe 3-4 times over the next couple years of our relationship, and it lasted maybe 5 seconds each time. No fetish play, even though I had specified the sort of bondage + tickling that turned me on in the letter. Not even any sort of fun, playful tickling as foreplay. NOTHING. When I tried to start tickle fights with him he would either get annoyed or just laugh for a second and then stop me--never tickle me back. WTF.
(For the record, I never asked to tickle him in my letter, I said the fetish was for him to do it to me)
His complete lack of interest in what I had expressed was my greatest turn on baffled and hurt me, but because I was so insecure and young at the time, I didn't have the guts to ask him about it. All I could think was there must be something disgusting about it (and me) if he wouldn't want to do it to me.
I eventually tried again with my most recent ex. It took a long time trying to explain it to him to finally get him to (sort of) do what I was wanting. I had some fun and sexy experiences with him and I'm glad I went for it, but sadly, he was a dick to me in other ways and I had to leave him.
All of these experiences left me pretty bummed, to be honest. I really don't understand why this is such a difficult thing for people to understand or do. If I'm so "beautiful" and "sexy" why wouldn't these guys want to turn me on and give me orgasms? Like the OP says, I would think tickling me would be funny and enjoyable for just about anyone, even if it wasn't their particular turn on. I DON'T GET IT!!!!!!!!!!!!