I think you're kind of missing the point, Cosmo.
I believe BrightEyes was addressing the POSTER's intent, not the Respondent's ...um... response.
Correct me if I'm wrong, but I believe we are discussing WHY, WHY, WHY the fuck would anyone stack the deck with a loaded query like this, then get upset when it blows up in their face?!?
I think she's got a helluva valid point!
And it needs to be addressed.
"The big, I mean HUGE picture question is: "Isn't that what this forum is all about?"
I certainly won't pretend I have the answer to that, because I believe the TMF is many thing to many people.
But I can feel BrightEyes' frustration radiating thru my monitor loud and clear.
I don't really feel like i'm missing anything, but then this thread has pretty much gone all over the place.
I feel that as a general discussion board, where people have been posting personal stuff for some time now, people are welcome to post what they want, within reason. If it seems like a person is posting constantly and seeming to post looking for specific responses, and you don't like this, then why bother reading or responding to the thread? It's funny, i see so many people in this thread, slamming mitch, because they are giving opinions that he doesn't like, and is not pleased with it, yet the same people constantly post responses? So whose really the worse person? The one posting the innitial post, or the people who keep coming back to said posts to post?
Don't care for the poster? Don't read the post. Give advice and it's not taken? Don't give anymore. After a while it looks like simple trolling, IMO.