• If you would like to get your account Verified, read this thread
  • Check out Tickling.com - the most innovative tickling site of the year.
  • The TMF is sponsored by Clips4sale - By supporting them, you're supporting us.
  • >>> If you cannot get into your account email me at [email protected] <<<
    Don't forget to include your username

Why do folks hate rap music so much?

jaba said:
Drew, your good humor has a way of easing the nail biting, suffocating tension in any thread, particularly on a topic as critical to the very existence of mankind as whether "rap qualifies as music"....

I disagree with some of your points, and I don't agree with your "a la carte" selection of definitions which suit your conclusions, but to fairly give your viewpoint clarification, and a fighting chance at survival.....

I guess the logical question is, what is the standard definition of "rap", and does this definition happily co-exist with your interpretation of the term?..... :idunno:

Funnily enough, dictionary.com doesn't have a definition for "rap" that applies, but it does have a definition for "RAP MUSIC"
 
bottom of the "ninth"....bases loaded?.....

ticklishgiggle said:
Funnily enough, dictionary.com doesn't have a definition for "rap" that applies, but it does have a definition for "RAP MUSIC"

Uh oh, Drew...... :illogical

Looks like the "Rap Music" team is making a "comeback rally" in the late innings of your "ballgame", my friend....... :jester:
 
jaba said:
I just started reading this thread....it has been very entertaining and informative, and I do not think that I have ever witnessed a broader display of knowledge and intelligence, and ignorance (lack of knowledge, not meant to be an insult) on one subject in all my years on this forum....

I have yet to see a conclusive answer to one question of mine....or I could have missed it

Does "Rap" or "Hip Hop" meet the standard, tecnical definition of "Music"? I hope no one takes issue or offense to my question, because it is simply a question with no hidden agenda.....

My limited knowledge (ignorance) of the broader definition of the word "music" is on display here....I believe rap is an "art form", but can "Rap" accurately be described as "music", notwithstanding its inclusion in Grammy and American music award ceremonies?

Great question. Let me begin by saying that we do not know of any culture that has ever existed without music. With that statement in mind, we need a sufficiently broad definition to encompass music from throughout the world and as far back as we have record. If the definition of harmony (and I suppose we need to define all terms) is the simultaneous sounding of two or more pitches, then it really doesn't belong in our definition of music- save to say that it can be a component of music. Harmony is perhaps the defining feature in differentiating Western music from the rest of the world. But in Western Music development, Greek music was essentially monophonic (a single unaccompanied melody- no harmony) as was the Early Christian music- everything up until around 900 A.D. Outside of the West, harmony often was non-existant long after the period of time we're talking about- and when it was introduced, it was sometimes due to Western influence. The word music, incidentally, is of Greek origin (mousikos- 'of the muses').

Most music contains melody- an organized succession of pitches. It does not have to, however. It's not difficult to lay one's hands on Latin music, music from Africa, music from India- actually music from any number of cultures including the West- that consists strictly of percussion insturments with no definite pitch (vibrations/sound waves do not occur in regular intervals) and thus has no melody. And if one chose to take a broader definition of melody (or harmony) as having nothing to do with definite pitch (regular vibrations), then we are left with a definition that is rather close to rhythm- the flow of music through time. Indeed, it is only rhythm, of the three musical elements I've so far mentioned, that is inherent to all music. For rhythm encompasses duration- once we produce a sound, however long that sound lasts is its duration. And when that sound cuts off, we've produced a measurement of time in music: rhythm.

So a workable definition of music might be something like 'organized sound that is intended to be listened to.' Taking into account the intentions of the person allows us to differentiate between someone creating a sound when trying to open a can of soup and someone beating on said can to create music. Rap/Hip-Hop is organized and intended to be listened to. Actually, most Hip-Hop has melody (could be a bass line, for example) and harmony (even if it's just sampled snippets), too. And some of it even has a principal melody or 'tune' that we can hum (I'll use Snow's 'Informer' as an example). But, regardless, all Hip-Hop has rhythm, and every piece of Hip-Hop I've ever heard had a beat (an even, recurring pulse)- a further aspect of rhythm. The rapping relates to the underlying pulse.

So, in conclusion (phew!), Rap/Hip-Hop is most certainly music.
 
Last edited:
(w)rap it up

I should provide a counter response to my previous post. Does anyone ever do that on this board? Clearly, it's ill-advised if one wants to at least appear sane.

As for my personal taste, my favorite Hip-Hop group was Cypress Hill- great rappers, great beats, decent awareness of music that came before them. I also liked Tribe Called Quest and the Beastie Boys. And I thought Public Enemy and Run DMC were good. Haven't heard newer stuff that did anything for me.

By biggest problem with Hip-Hop was the sampling. Just because this technology was available and so many people were using it didn't make it right. And one thing that bothered me as a musician (and I've never heard anyone else voice this) was that you may sample me and have me playing on your recording when I (A) never agreed to play on it and (B) am not getting paid for it. The industry became satisfied once they were able to sue and collect on the music they own that is being sampled. But what about the musicians? 'Funky Drummer,' the James Brown tune, must be the most widely sampled song ever. And Clyde Stubblefield is the funky drummer. But do you suppose he ever received a nickel for all the new music he appeared on? And he didn't agree to appear on those recordings- the whole thing was 'acceptable' just because it was so widely practiced and the people in power got theirs...


Oh, yes, and in response (or in addition) to my previous post, here is the Merriam-Webster's online dictionary's definition of music which seems relatively broad (http://www.m-w.com/dictionary/music):

1 a : the science or art of ordering tones or sounds in succession, in combination, and in temporal relationships to produce a composition having unity and continuity b : vocal, instrumental, or mechanical sounds having rhythm, melody, or harmony
 
if it has a beat and gets my subs pumping its music...

I have listened to 2pac, Diddy, L L, Ja, CNN, Capone, N.O.R.E, Chingy, N.W.A, Eazy E, Ice T and Cube, Dre, Snoop, Biggie, Nas, Bone Thugs, Deep, Outlawz, Houston, 7th Floor Crew, X, Crazie, Kastro, H&S, Sticky Fingaz, Oynx, Westside Connection, Boyz N Da Hood, Jerzey Mob, Black Rob, Master P and whole lot more plus a lot of underground shit....my point is that it would hard for me to recall any song about rape or raping 'bitches'...

and while im throwing in my 34 dollars and 69 cents....screaming into a microphone doesnt exactly emphasise musical genius...

Ku5t
 
quick!...somebody grab the defibrillator!.....

CitY of MicA said:
Great question. Let me begin by saying that we do not know of any culture that has ever existed without music. With that statement in mind, we need a sufficiently broad definition to encompass music from throughout the world and as far back as we have record. If the definition of harmony (and I suppose we need to define all terms) is the simultaneous sounding of two or more pitches, then it really doesn't belong in our definition of music- save to say that it can be a component of music. Harmony is perhaps the defining feature in differentiating Western music from the rest of the world. But in Western Music development, Greek music was essentially monophonic (a single unaccompanied melody- no harmony) as was the Early Christian music- everything up until around 900 A.D. Outside of the West, harmony often was non-existant long after the period of time we're talking about- and when it was introduced, it was sometimes due to Western influence. The word, incidentally, is of Greek origin (mousikos- 'of the muses').

Most music contains melody- an organized succession of pitches. It does not have to, however. It's not difficult to lay one's hands on Latin music, music from Africa, or music from India- actually music from any number of cultures- that consists strictly of percussion insturments with no definite pitch (vibrations/sound waves do not occur in regular intervals) and thus has no melody. And if one chose to take a broader definition of melody (or harmony) as having nothing to do with definite pitch (regular vibrations), then we are left with a definition that is rather close to rhythm- the flow of music through time. Indeed, it is only rhythm, of the three musical elements I've so far mentioned, that is inherent to all music. For rhythm encompasses duration- once we produce a sound, however long that sound lasts is it's duration. And when that sound cuts off, we've produced a measurement of time in music: rhythm.

So a workable definition of music might be something like 'organized sound that is intended to be listened to.' Taking into account the intentions of the person allows us to differentiate between someone creating a sound when trying to open a can of soup and someone beating on said can to create music. Rap/Hip-Hop is organized and intended to be listened to. Actually, most Hip-Hop has melody and harmony, too. And some of it even has a principal melody or 'tune' that we can hum (I'll use Snow's 'Informer' as an example). But, regardless, all Hip-Hop has rhythm, and every piece of Hip-Hop I've ever heard had a beat (an even, recurring pulse)- a further aspect of rhythm. The rapping relates to the underlying pulse.

So, in conclusion (phew!), Rap/Hip-Hop is most certainly music.

Drew?......Drew?.....care to respond?...:xpeepsofa

It appears that your assertion that "rap is not music" ....is on "life support"...... :cool2:
 
And remember that not only is rap recognized by the big time music shows but it also has won an oscar. "Three 6 Mafia, Academy Award winners."
 
Reasons why I hate gangster rap.

First off I want to say, I've listened to rap from the popular stuff that comes out to the older stuff that was Later 80s to early 90s. I want to say not all rap is bad, and some is GOOD. The thing isn't a matter of 'hating black people', or hating any race. I do my best not to judge anyone, and I know I'm not racist, cause I hang out with Africans to Mexicans to Asians to any type of race. The thing I hate is not the old rap, it's the new one. The one that's mainly mainstream, not the stuff that hasn't been played.

"...hoping no one had yet said what it turned out Jerry had said already, so I could be the first one. Oh well. I agree with ya though, Jerry...though rap was once spirited and fun back in the '80's, when it was taken far less seriously and "Gangsta" rap hadn't yet descended upon us. Gimme The Fat Boys, Run DMC, DJ Jazzy Jeff and The Fresh Prince, and MC Hammer from his first two albums any day."

There was a Yahoo news report, and one hip hop rapper said, "You don't know a genre till you've listened to it's roots." Well I have listened to the roots, and dislike like the top part, not the roots. The stuff you don't see is good, and the stuff you do see is bad. This gives a bad name to rap, and hip hop.


"Despite your beliefs, you DO need vocal talent to become a successful rap artist. Guys like 2pac, Snoop, Ice Cube and even Eminem have distinct voices and rap styles which is why they are successful. Not everyone who raps is good at it."

Vocal talent isn't true, unless you're changing your voice. Lil' Jon gets paided just to make beats. If he makes a beat, he gets paid over $1000, is that talent? No, it's not.

Is everyone good at rap? No, that's obivious, not everyone can rock, not everyone can do country, not everyone can do anything. This is were ALOT of stereotypes come. The pharse, "White people can't jump." is from this kind of stuff. It's not hard to make the stuff Lil' Jon does if you have the computer software, as Goodie stated. It's when you have to use it like Poetry, and have to come up with off the top of your head.

"The extemporaniety was the key element; those guys were the most amazing right-off-the-top-of-their-head wordsmiths! I admired the hell out of them. I listen to rap every now and then, by getting the cds from the library.
I'm always dissappointed, comparing the brainless repetetive garbage that passes for rap now with the sheer verbal artistry, the dazzling brilliance I used to hear in the streets of NYC."

Though streets of NYC is not where was always there, but this is the type of Rap that's good. The type were instead of fighting, instead of wasting time of killing gang violence when there is no reason to fight. They came up with a good way of settling difference, though putting down is easy, but you won't like everything of one thing. Even if some of it is still messed up, I don't think people should make of them if they don't know them (Your mom jokes piss me off the most, excluding them actually being jokes), so maybe it wasn't all good. Though it's better than people dying, and it was creative.

"I would like to see a "rap hater" go out to the urban areas where rap music is constantly being played and tell those young kids that they have no real talent if they rap and that the artists they listen to are no good and talentless. That will go over real well....."

This wasn't a good comment, it's like saying, "Walk up to a cop, and call him a pig. Than offer to buy a him doughnuts, and coffee." Well obiviously if you go to a Gangster place, and say, "You suck." there not going to be happy.


"I wish you could meet Dr. Dre and tell him he has no talent for creating music. I wish you could meet Snoop and tell him he has no vocal talent. You would be laughed off the face of the Earth...."

You took this to personal which means you are making yourself lose a debate. When you take things to the point of trying to insult the other person with out a reason behind it, excluding getting mad. Than you are not doing so good. Als I'd gladly tell Snoop dog, he should stop being gangster, and please rap to help out. Though he'd probably try to say I was nobody, or that my mom is something of hore. Than I'd only feel that I was more right, and people would laugh, but it's only cause the people around are in that gangster fade.


"I do find it hard to understand why people would hate something and think they know so much about the "talent level" of rap artists if they never actually listened to the artists. Guys like 2pac and Ice Cube actually rap about the ills of society and have made songs that are positive. But, rap haters wouldn't know that because they do not listen to their songs."

But I have listen to there songs, both sobber, and not. The only time I thought it was good was when I wasn't sobber, and I haven't heard a postive rap song from 2pac, or Ice cube. You can give me some, I'll pull lyrics, and be happy to either agree, or disagree. Though mind most time people create a song that they say is good, it's usually just cause someone makes them feel bad. Than they continue, being hypocritical to that song.

"Ticklerguy4u, you are right. This is exactly what this thread is about. I want people to whine, complain, bitch, rant and give every reason why they hate rap. I hope it makes their soul feel better...."

It's not right to rant in others thread, I don't know about it, and don't really blame you for being mad. Though to say that your mad, because they disliked it is like saying you've never done it. Which we all have one time, or another. People want to state there opinion bad, or good. If you don't like it, you should state for people who don't to make another thread, or ask them to not.

"By the way, if you do criticize a pro athlete, it is helpful that you are an athlete, otherwise how can you judge someone's athletic skills? I don't watch soccer, and you'll never hear me criticize any soccer player for their athletic skills. Become familiar with a topic before you criticize it, otherwise you can look stupid."

....Just cause I'm not an athlete, doesn't mean I can't say. "Wow this guy isn't to great." Maybe I feel he should pratice more, and try harder. Maybe I've watched a ton of soccer to know how he should be doing, or I've educated myself on it by reading about it. There are ways besides being an athlete. I can't draw, but I can tell others how there art looks.


"I can see why people wouldn't like hip-hop because of the things that are rapped about. However, when they are rapping about these things they are just telling us about their lives somewhat. Some rap artists were involved in drugs, violence & other things before they were put on. They know nothing else other than these things so thats what they rap about. They could be more creative but I don't have a problem with hearing about those types of things. Hot music is hot music and I don't really care what they are rapping about. I like many types of music, current and past, and I can listen to all forms of hip-hop/rap."

If my life was about me killing people, stealing, doing drugs, disregarding women, and other stuff. Than I say it's good, or even if that's all I know so I just say that's my story. I think that's not thought out, anyone can do it. Trying to say how bad it is, and how we need to get better than it is much harder when you grew up in that life style, and are a part of it.


"I don't think anything of the opinion of people who don't listen to rap. Funny how these people want to slam rap but don't know a damn thing about it. People who like rap even notice it's flaws and express the same negative sentiments that have been posted in this thread. It's just that people here are posting completely ignorant statements w/o fully understanding what they are speaking about. I feel the same way about these people you see on TV (CNN, FOX News, etc.) trying to tell us why hip-hop is bad. There are other art forms that express real HATE music but you never hear anyone complaining about them. There are rock artists and groups who express advocate violence and racism in their music. I wouldn't make a general statement about a music genre based on a few songs, especially if I don't listen to that type of music extensively. I don't like country music, but I respect the fact that they have great, legendary musicians who are worthy of being recognized as such. I wouldn't dispute a claim by anyone who wants to tell me that a certain country musician is one of the all-time greats, because I don't listen to the music. Hip-hop is much bigger than what is heard on the radio or seen on TV, but most of you will never understand."

It's funnier how most of these people are listeing to Mainstream, and telling you that's what they hate. Though it's not general, but some people might dislike general they don't hate it. By dislike, it just not being in there taste. There statements aren't ignorate, and how would you know. Do you know these people? Do you know they haven't listen to rap music, and just heard one song, or something? It's true there are bad rock bands, and country music, and other types. Though the difference being, that rap happens to have a bad rap, one since it went in a new direction of its older self. I don't listen to alot of country music, I don't know any large names, but I dislike certain songs I've heard. Though I like certain ones to, but when I want to joke about one song I've heard. When I don't that ONE songs name, I use country music. Though it doesn't mean I fully hate, dislike, and completely utterly think country sucks. Sometimes one song ruins the bunch, sometimes it doesn't.

"rap from years and years ago was very tame in comparison to the more recent years, and the fact that parents let their kids listen to it (the same parents who bitch and moan about the violence in video games...trust me, i know some of those people) without really blinking bothers me."

This is sad, but true. Also it's Gangster rap again.

"

another thing that bothers me about rap is that the vast majority of the fans that listen to it have the innate need to blast it out of their speakers as they cruise oh-so-slowly through the streets, as if the neighborhood wishes for that kind of "entertainment". i do my best to ignore it, but sometimes the bass is set to the point that it sounds like the car is rattling apart as it ambles down the road."

Has anyone heard a rock song, a country song, or any other song coming from outside someone elses car? I've heard metal, but that, and only rap. The bad gangster rap again.


"I've been listening to hip-hop since 1979. I admit the rappers talk about a lot of negitive things in their music but I've never heard a raper talk about or glorify rape. Why would you want to rape a woman when women everywhere are throwing themselves at you??? I even asked my little brother (he's 30 btw) whom I consider " the Hip-hop God", had he ever heard a raper talk about rape. He couldn't think of one artist that did.
Question: I find it very interesting that so many White folks dislike or despise hip-hop when, according to record sales, that the majority of people(aprox 70 percent) who purchas hip- hop are white. Why is that?? Remember hip-hop was underground in the black commuinty for many years. These guy's and girls didn't get rich off of black folks..
Further more, why has cooporate america jumped on the hip-hop band wagon? Every movie trailer and soda commercial has a hip-hop theme to it. Just wondering....."

I think there was a song, or two. Though I have no idea the name, I remember hearing it. Though the reason rape comes into play, is because gangsters rape alot. When you say women throw them at you, I do see alot of sluts, harlets(*****s), and other women who always have something bad about them doing it. That's Gangster rap again.

Your talking about Gangster rap with sales. Most rap that does get money is cause it's a fade. It's one of those music genres where the mainstream kinda went not so good. Though when it's popular alot of white people did puchase it, I won't say 70%. That seems to high to me, maybe 55%ish.


Last few things, alot of rockers do drugs. Which I admit is incredibly uncool. Though rockers themselves don't have MUSIC with alot of straight out saying, "Drugs are good." Some songs have inuendo. Which is a huge difference, why you ask? That's cause when it goes on mainstream, unless it's pretty obivious, most kids over 14 usually know. Though kids under don't. With rap, theres nothing, it's just plain says it. Mind you there is inuendo on some songs. Though it's made it WAY to easy, and to the point were kids that are 10 and under say words they shouldn't. Kids not in highschool are trying to be Gangster, they are trying to do these things.

With sex, I'm cool with trying to get down, and all. Though inuendo comes into play, and most of the time Gangster rap is basically *****s. Which means when it's fade, every girl out there tries to become one. This in turn makes any woman's hard work at trying to make women gain rights go down the toliet in my opinion. It's kinda the same for race, but not so much. I feel that when Gangster rap was really became a huge part of my everyday life, which it is. I feel that it makes that race sound lower, and less intelligent. Don't get me wrong, but it makes any one man who stood up for his race's rights seem to go down the toliet. It makes me wonder why people can even still try to make race such an issue, when people tried so hard to get rid of it. I feel bad for those who spent there LIFEs trying to make that race become equal, all to have people piss on it.

I'm not saying anyone's opinion is wrong, but you have to draw a line somewhere. Gangster rap isn't cool, and in no way needs to be around. Rap from 80s to 90s(early) is fine, and good.

No offense to anyone, but I'd like to point out a friend once told me rap standed for, "Retards Attempting Poetry." Though I don't think it's intirely true with all people, I can understand were it came from. Thought I should share that detail. Any good rap in my book is hip hop. Anything as rap is usually bad.

Hope I didn't offend people, I tried not to.
 
Why do folks hate rap music so much?

Because folks hate stupidity.

I mean, come on. How retarded do you have to be to come up with some shit like "B to the izzo"?

I don't think I have ever seen a single lyric sheet for a rap 'song' that was spelled correctly, through and through.
 
ViperGTS said:
Why do folks hate rap music so much?

Because folks hate stupidity.

I mean, come on. How retarded do you have to be to come up with some shit like "B to the izzo"?

I don't think I have ever seen a single lyric sheet for a rap 'song' that was spelled correctly, through and through.



as I stated in my first post, I do not think that I have ever witnessed a thread with a broader display of intelligence, and ignorance, on one subject in all my years on this forum...



this thread has degraded past the point of intelligibility for me... :wavingguy
 
jaba said:
Drew?......Drew?.....care to respond?...:xpeepsofa

It appears that your assertion that "rap is not music" ....is on "life support"...... :cool2:
Ah, but appearances are often deceiving, my good Jaba. A body can appear lifeless when it is merely at rest, gaining strength. 😀 But you asked for a response, and you shall have it, sir!

Mikey's little history lesson and subsequent comments only serve to support what I've been saying. He's quite effectively demonstrated that in order for rap to qualify as music, we must broaden the definition of music to include all the stepping stones of it's development through history. This is akin to redefining "car" to include any historical mode of transport, to include horse and buggy, or even the wheel. This does not speak well for rap. If qualifying rap as music requires us to broaden our definition of music to include less developed forms of it, then it suggests that rap is a step backward in music development, a GIANT step in my personal opinion.

I personally don't share Mikey's need to include all historical forms of ritual chants, wailings and utterances in our definition of music. I think it's far more reasonable to define music as what is taught by schools of music--That which is defined by the chromatic 12 note scale, the components of today's scales and modes. From these scales and modes are derived virtually all styles of music of the last several centuries.

That is what I'M talking about when I say rap is not music. It is at best, atonal. At worst, monotonal. In some cases a musical backdrop is included, as in the clip ticklishgiggle provided. The result is a combination of music and dissonance, being passed off as music. This is analogous to the guy who instead of showering away his offensive BO, splashes on cologne in an attempt to justify his odor, but it just doesn't work.
 
Last edited:
I'd say that anything you can dance to, meaning anything that has a beat, is music. So, rap is music to me. Although, heavy metal is my favorite kind of music. Head banging is a type of dancing in my opinion haha. So, I think heavy metal is music too.
 
I can turn on my washing machine, and dance to it's rhythm. But I don't consider that music. Heavy metal, though screaming and distorted, is still based on the 12 note chromatic scale, and as such definitely qualifies as music.
 
drew70 said:
I can turn on my washing machine, and dance to it's rhythm. But I don't consider that music. Heavy metal, though screaming and distorted, is still based on the 12 note chromatic scale, and as such definitely qualifies as music.


and heavy metal is heavily influenced in structure by classical music movements. But i will admit there are some bands that are worthless in the metal genre
 
ViperGTS said:
Why do folks hate rap music so much?

Because folks hate stupidity.

I mean, come on. How retarded do you have to be to come up with some shit like "B to the izzo"?

I don't think I have ever seen a single lyric sheet for a rap 'song' that was spelled correctly, through and through.

Behold, my young friend, a rap song spelled correctly...



Artist: Immortal Technique
Album: Revolutionary Vol. 1
Title: Speak Your Mind

[Intro]
You have to speak the truth
You have to speak your mind

[Verse 1]
Every time I speak my mind I'm lyrically critical
The pinnacle of being revolutionarily pivotal
Beyond anything ever studied thats metaphysical
Man fuck a minority, I'm not politically minimal
But obviously terminologies that are statistical
Are manufactured to be unequivocally subliminal
Transmitted by monopolized media visuals
So I riddle hypocritically pitiful criminals
Habitually utilizing typical rituals
With false pretense in attempts to be spiritual
To individuals who believe in biblical miracles
Instead of themselves, because they're not thinking original
And the color of their skin makes them feel invisible
Like microscopic miscarriages lynched with the umbilical
Only a fucking imbecile would think they're uncorrectable
Cause your susceptible to becoming more than a spectacle
Remember that your flesh your blood and you body are dissectable
Ill beat you until your vegetable
And wake up in a hospital covered in poisonous chemicals
In a fetal position with your face sewn to your testicles
Thinking that you were kidnapped by extraterrestrials
You got heart? I'm the blood that pumps in your ventricles
Technique, I'm like your soul... indispensable
Wit no respect for those that cower at the hour of revolution
'Cause the government owes my people restitution
Instead of sedatives like cocaine and prostitution
Conclusion is that you'll have to violently silence me
'Cause I raid the airwaves of cutthroat piracy
In school my teachers blinded me
But now I can see
I'm mentally and revolutionarily free
Broadening Horizons about what my people could be
If we wasn't set up to get shot locked or OD
You see families bleed because of corporate greed
And monopolizing weed is virtually impossible
So it wont be legalized and thats another obstacle
But I'm still rolling up pocket fulls of tropical
The governments involved directly so its unstoppable
Like a nuclear rocket full of biochemical toxins that invade the ecological
Improbable that the average intellect could understand
So I encrypted this into hip hop thats in high demand
and spread it through the ghetto of every city like contraband
Stomp a man of any complexion with a devilish nature
Because I'm trying to save the earth, but you're just next in line to rape her
 
subZer0 said:
In response:

I'd like to say that it is a good idea to keep the other thread as clean from opinions instead of what it was created for by creating this one, so good on you, primtime.

I like some rap songs. It's like any other genre. I'm mostly Metal/Rock anyway, but it doesn't stop me liking whatever pleases me to listen to. Granted, I do hear some God-awful rap songs in my opinion, but I also hear some God-awful R&B, Nu-Metal, Metal, Rock, Dance, Trance, etc, etc....

However, primetime, I have an observation; why do you invite people to whinge moan, etc, about a particular genre of music, but then immediately ask those people to bear in mind that their distaste insults an entire culture? Surely, if you have encouraged a medium for venting such distaste, you expect there to be negative opinions about it?! And why, if they have opinions, should they have to bear that in mind? If I dislike a particular sport, and I have a valid reason for it, I don't expect to have to bear in mind that the followers of that particular sport may be offended. I expect everyone to have their own valid opinions, and that they respect mine.

Thanks for your time!

i agree with this post..this thread is supposed to be about those who hate or dislike rap music and to explain their reasons..those that have attempted to do that have been rather insulted by others..or ridiculed..
 
then what do we call....... a "baby Drew"?

drew70 said:
Ah, but appearances are often deceiving, my good Jaba. A body can appear lifeless when it is merely at rest, gaining strength. 😀 But you asked for a response, and you shall have it, sir!

Great news!.....and a "living, breathing, responding" Drew will always be jaba's "preferred" Drew, if given a choice!.... :twohugs:



If qualifying rap as music requires us to broaden our definition of music to include less developed forms of it, then it suggests that rap is a step backward in music development, a GIANT step in my personal opinion.


does qualifing our beloved TMF member "Drew" as "human" require us to include "lesser developed" forms of him? :shock:

do we define the cooing, :cry1: gurgling, "baby Drew" as....."not human"?....



and even if "rap" takes a step so far backward in "MUSICAL" development" that "Grandmaster Flash and the Furious Five" hold a concert in "Jurrasic Park", I still am unclear on how it's lesser developed "musical form" form disqualifies it as......"music", particularly in light of some pretty intelligent, convincing arguements of others here that respectfully disagree with you? (notwithstanding one "intelligent" individual on this thread that dismisses rap as a "musical art form" because it is, as he describes it...."stupid"..... :sowrong: )


I personally don't share Mikey's need to include all historical forms of ritual chants, wailings and utterances in our definition of music. I think it's far more reasonable to define music as what is taught by schools of music
.

ha ha....you should have been in jaba's grade school introductory music class! All you could hear were horrific "chants, wailings and utterances" when when a music test arrived unannounced..... by definition, it was still music, though admittedly a "bloodcurdling" form of it....... :scared:


once again, our beloved Drew is pondering the "a la carte" page of the "music definition" menu...c'mon Drew...splurge a little!...try the "combination plate"!... 😎

I mean....by definition, it's all "food", even the "underdeveloped portions" of it, right?..... :illogical


like a "baby Drew", jaba is abdorbing, ingesting, and digesting the various responses here.....but is sure sounds like "rap" still qualifies as "music" to me.....albiet a "lesser developed" form of it.....
 
isabeau said:
i agree with this post..this thread is supposed to be about those who hate or dislike rap music and to explain their reasons..those that have attempted to do that have been rather insulted by others..or ridiculed..

That's because a lot of people having made statements that aren't true at all. If you hate rap then you obviously don't know a damn thing about it. There are people who listen to rap and don't like the stuff being played today, but none of those people are writing in this thread. I feel that some of the statements that people have made have been insults to certain rappers or rap in general. So if that person gets insulted they must deserve it.
 
ticklishgiggle said:
Behold, my young friend, a rap song spelled correctly...

Yay, you found one. I'm so proud of you! Would you like a cookie?

Take a joke, little girl.
 
Tickle_Fiend05 said:
That's because a lot of people having made statements that aren't true at all. If you hate rap then you obviously don't know a damn thing about it. There are people who listen to rap and don't like the stuff being played today, but none of those people are writing in this thread. I feel that some of the statements that people have made have been insults to certain rappers or rap in general. So if that person gets insulted they must deserve it.


So you cannot hate anything then, because if you hate something, then you dont know anything about it?
 
Tickle_Fiend05 said:
That's because a lot of people having made statements that aren't true at all. If you hate rap then you obviously don't know a damn thing about it.

And you actually regard this statement you just made as......"true"?

Does your same opinion apply to classical music?
 
jaba said:
does qualifing our beloved TMF member "Drew" as "human" require us to include "lesser developed" forms of him? :shock:

do we define the cooing, :cry1: gurgling, "baby Drew" as....."not human"?....
Hah. Well, admittedly I'm certainly not the most mature forum member, but I like to think I've passed beyond the cooing, gurgling stage. I guess it's all a matter of perception. When one feels strongly about an issue, the tendancy is to regard those who disagree as ignorant, uninformed, or perhaps even gurgling cooing babies. 😉

jaba said:
and even if "rap" takes a step so far backward in "MUSICAL" development" that "Grandmaster Flash and the Furious Five" hold a concert in "Jurrasic Park", I still am unclear on how it's lesser developed "musical form" form disqualifies it as......"music", particularly in light of some pretty intelligent, convincing arguements of others here that respectfully disagree with you?
Well, I'm hoping my arguments are at least as intelligent, convincing, and in respectful disagreement with those you mention. 🙂

One could argue that a child's fingerpainting is "art," but would you honestly expect to see it in an art gallery? If fingerpainting was the best mankind had to offer then yes, I suppose we would. But just like modern music offers melody, harmony, orchestra, etc, modern art gives us brushes, pallettes, shades, and hues.

Imagine if you would, stick figure pencil art becoming popular, now rendering those with no artistic tallent to suddenly become artistes en vogue. That's basically what's happened with rap.

jaba said:
ha ha....you should have been in jaba's grade school introductory music class! All you could hear were horrific "chants, wailings and utterances" when when a music test arrived unannounced..... by definition, it was still music, though admittedly a "bloodcurdling" form of it....... :scared:
Well then, that's where we differ. I wouldn't call it music. But of course, one must learn to crawl, before one can learn to walk.

jaba said:
once again, our beloved Drew is pondering the "a la carte" page of the "music definition" menu...c'mon Drew...splurge a little!...try the "combination plate"!... 😎
Sorry, I'm on a diet. Doctor's orders. 😉

jaba said:
I mean....by definition, it's all "food", even the "underdeveloped portions" of it, right?..... :illogical
In the broadest sense of the term, I suppose so, but if I ordered food from a restaurant and got undercooked meat, or unripened fruit, I would definitely have a word with the manager. :cool2:
 
"If you hate rap, you obviously don't know a damn thing about it"?????

Wait a minute...I could NOT have possibly read that right, because, and I mean no disrespect, there's no logic in that statement whatsoever. It seems to imply that people that like rap music "understand" it, and those who dislike it couldn't possibly have an informed opinion. My opinion, and it IS just an opinion, DOES nevertheless happen to be very, VERY informed. I'm a former professional disk jockey, and I've spun more different genres of tunes than many of you are even aware of, which is not to say YOUR opinions aren't valid, merely reinforcing the fact that mine, I feel, is. I don't think rap is music. Where are the instruments? Where's are the notes on a sheet? It's fabricated, synchronized and assembly-line computer generated, and half of THAT isn't even original: I've never seen any genre of actual music engage so liberally in "sampling" beats and tunes from other songs. So whether we should call it "music" or not (we shouldn't), though easy enough to determine, isn't really the point of the thread. I think the very nature of rap, the levels of controversy and notoriety it aspires to, makes it far, far easier to dislike. Rap obviously caters to a fairly select audience, and I'm sure any rap artist would admit that that is his intent with what he creates, and to insist that rap is in ANY way derivative of the blues or whatever other forms of actual music some people insist it takes its "roots" from just doesn't add up. Let's not make rap out to be more than it is. For some very rare few artists, it might be, but on the whole rap is about as much like the blues as Taco Bell is like Red Lobster. If you like rap, swell. Fine. Peachy. But PLEASE don't try to pass it off as some incredibly grandiose, deeply-researched, complex art form...heck, it's not even music. I don't like it because of much of the lyrical content and the fact that there is not a single musical instrument to be found in any of it. AND it's not music. But I don't "hate" it. Hate's far too strong a word to apply to really anything. I merely dislike it and, since the original question of the thread was for people to explain why they don't like it, I feel I've accomplished that aim rather well. And I most certainly DO know a "damn thing" about it too, I might add...now, let's move on with our lives and lay down some Fat Boys tracks.
 
Yeah!

ticklishgiggle said:
Behold, my young friend, a rap song spelled correctly...



Artist: Immortal Technique
Album: Revolutionary Vol. 1
Title: Speak Your Mind

[Intro]
You have to speak the truth
You have to speak your mind

[Verse 1]
Every time I speak my mind I'm lyrically critical
The pinnacle of being revolutionarily pivotal
Beyond anything ever studied thats metaphysical
Man fuck a minority, I'm not politically minimal
But obviously terminologies that are statistical
Are manufactured to be unequivocally subliminal
Transmitted by monopolized media visuals
So I riddle hypocritically pitiful criminals
Habitually utilizing typical rituals
With false pretense in attempts to be spiritual
To individuals who believe in biblical miracles
Instead of themselves, because they're not thinking original
And the color of their skin makes them feel invisible
Like microscopic miscarriages lynched with the umbilical
Only a fucking imbecile would think they're uncorrectable
Cause your susceptible to becoming more than a spectacle
Remember that your flesh your blood and you body are dissectable
Ill beat you until your vegetable
And wake up in a hospital covered in poisonous chemicals
In a fetal position with your face sewn to your testicles
Thinking that you were kidnapped by extraterrestrials
You got heart? I'm the blood that pumps in your ventricles
Technique, I'm like your soul... indispensable
Wit no respect for those that cower at the hour of revolution
'Cause the government owes my people restitution
Instead of sedatives like cocaine and prostitution
Conclusion is that you'll have to violently silence me
'Cause I raid the airwaves of cutthroat piracy
In school my teachers blinded me
But now I can see
I'm mentally and revolutionarily free
Broadening Horizons about what my people could be
If we wasn't set up to get shot locked or OD
You see families bleed because of corporate greed
And monopolizing weed is virtually impossible
So it wont be legalized and thats another obstacle
But I'm still rolling up pocket fulls of tropical
The governments involved directly so its unstoppable
Like a nuclear rocket full of biochemical toxins that invade the ecological
Improbable that the average intellect could understand
So I encrypted this into hip hop thats in high demand
and spread it through the ghetto of every city like contraband
Stomp a man of any complexion with a devilish nature
Because I'm trying to save the earth, but you're just next in line to rape her
Now THAT was poetry, practically crying to be set to music!
It rhymed, it scanned, it had an internal rythym and beat. Just reciting it out loud as a poem, I could hear the music it was written for.
That reminds me of the old time stuff I used to hear on the streets of NYC.
This is the kind of wordsmithing that is absent from most current and /or 'gangsta'' rap, which is why I'm so down on that stuff.
I wonder if the guy who wrote this can spin stuff that good off the top of his head the way the rappers I used to hear did? That would be freakin' awesome!
 
What's New

3/5/2025
Visit Clips4Sale for the webs largest one-stop fetish clip store.
Door 44
Live Camgirls!
Live Camgirls
Streaming Videos
Pic of the Week
Pic of the Week
Congratulations to
*** brad1701 ***
The winner of our weekly Trivia, held every Sunday night at 11PM EST in our Chat Room
Back
Top